Friday, June 29, 2012

Has a Biochem Undergrad Solved a Cosmic Radiation Mystery?

That's the proof of a supernova in 774?

Yeah, that's credible.

One wonders what the "wonderful serpents" were.

You're simply not going to get a definitive record of a celestial event in 8th century Europe. Records are very scanty, often non-existent. This is so marked that it's led to an entertaining conspiracy theory [wikipedia.org] or two [wikipedia.org] claiming that the early Middle Ages didn't actually exist and were faked at some later date. Back in the real world, there's so little evidence for most things about Anglo-Saxon England that the claim that the people of York chose Ethelred, son of Mull to be their king is almost as suspect as the claim about the wonderful serpents.

So the best you can usually hope for in the English 8th century is a monk somewhere recording events in the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle (or a Anglo-Saxon Chronicle -- there were a few of them made at different times and in different places). The Chronicle doesn't really go for detail. They sum up a year in a few declarative sentences, with no description, so you're never going to get a description of a celestial event, you're going to get a simplfied interpretation of it. This interpretation will be in terms that the monk or the eyewitnesses he got his information from understood. They didn't know anything about supernovas, but he knew about miraculous crosses in the sky, like that which appeared to the future Roman Emperor Constantine during his fighting against his rival Maxentius. So whatever it was that someone saw, it got interpreted as a crucifix.

The point isn't that something definitely appeared in the sky in 774. There's a chance that someone made up the red crucifx, or hallucinated it, or the chronicler lied or garbled a story he heard fifth-hand. But if it did happen, there's no reason to think that there will be better written evidence than a vague line in one copy of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle.

Source: http://rss.slashdot.org/~r/Slashdot/slashdotScience/~3/pJZpr_-kb8w/has-a-biochem-undergrad-solved-a-cosmic-radiation-mystery

ann romney tupac hologram tupac back tax deadline death race buffet rule carlos santana

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.